32 Star Island Rd
Montauk, NY 11954
Dock
Offered
Mooring
Not Offered
Day Trip
Not Offered
Book faster with the free Dockwa app
281 Reviews
by Sandra R. - Verified user on Jul 25, 2026
Wonderful stay. The only thing that was a bit strange was that our boat was moved and we were not notified.
by Frank P. - Verified user on Jul 22, 2026
Great time as always
John the dockmaster and his crew I are the BEST!!!
by Gregory F. - Verified user on Jul 14, 2026
Great stay. Beautiful facility. Dockhands are terrific. The facility is over the top, from the bar, the Spa to the pools. Just a great visit from every perspective.
by raffaele g. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2026
Always great time. Dockhands and dockmaster always gracious and professional. See you soon!!!
by Prestige Marine Management Services L. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2026
The dock staff was very accommodating. We had a really nice stay
by Guy P. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2026
Great way to spend the weekend. Pools are great and staff is very helpful and friendly
by Sal V. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2026
Perfect Marina - clean docks, bathrooms and grounds. Professional and courteous dock staff. Highly recommend !
by Mark M. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2026
Excellent place to dock up!
by Jeffrey D. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2026
Great staff. Fun place to be.
by Marc P. - Verified user on Jul 11, 2026
First time at the marina, very nice experience between the really good dock hands, nice bathrooms and showers, pools and availability of bikes and a shuttle van into town, overall great experience and I hope to return.
by David S. - Verified user on Jul 09, 2026
It really has everything and nothing quite compares to it (tennis, spa, good running, great food, only 2 miles from Ditch Plains and short Uber to town or use the Hampton Hopper or free transport in by hotel - we used all three). You can be remote as you want or not. Though the menu is limited at ALBA (new restaurant) we thought the food was very good with the lobster fettuccine and Accanto salad were excellent. Pool bar burger was solid.
This is on my list of best in class marinas that we visit. Electric has been upgraded to mostly GFCI power pedestals, docks have been attended to and dockhands know what they are doing which takes some stress out of the equation. I had an electric issue on my boat and John the Dockmaster and a dockhand spent an hour in 90 degree heat helping me diagnose the issue as we tried all sorts of combinations of power. Determined my Isoboost was the issue and fixed issue by setting it to by pass. Then the dockhand spent extra time adjusting my lines to account for the tide while keeping my boarding step system on the narrow finger pier (boat didn’t budge when the weather turned on the 4th with 30 mile an hour guats). In all my years of boating, I have never had such attention and desire to help at another marina. And they were very busy that day which really speaks volumes about their commitment to visiting boaters.
Will come back for sure.
by Joseph J. - Verified user on Jul 06, 2026
Would highly recommend. I’ve been coming here for several years, dockmaster and crew always run a tight ship. professional, organized, and consistently provide excellent service. Also excellent amenities on property restaurant , pool , outdoor bar, gift shop. Everything you need to spend a few days or longer.
by William F. - Verified user on Jul 06, 2026
Pleasant stay.
Great dock staff
by Timothy D. - Verified user on Jul 05, 2026
Great service and a fun environment. Only drawback is they lack a fuel dock. Loved it.
by Lance B. - Verified user on Jul 02, 2026
Again the staff performs well. Great dockmaster. Love the grounds and Mtk.
by Dane C. - Verified user on Jun 29, 2026
This is one of the nicest marinas I have ever stayed at. The resort is beautiful. The restaurant was outstanding and reasonably priced, all things considered. No complaints about anything whatsoever. The marina staff could not have been more helpful and courteous.
by Rob G. - Verified user on Jun 28, 2026
Bathrooms, particularly at end of dock can use updating. Good property.
by Martha J. - Verified user on Jun 26, 2026
John, Guy and the whole crew are absolutely great. Their are the reason we stay there!!!
by david w. - Verified user on Jun 25, 2026
Beautiful spot - huge property. Facilities are top notch. Complimentary bikes were great plus. Couple things to know - docks are fixed. Super short finger piers. Tennis not included in resort fee you pay. They charge additional to plug in. For $400 a night I’d expect not to be paying extras for everything.
by Tim C. - Verified user on Jun 23, 2026
John Waters & Guy Pepitone always make our stay special. Dock hands like David & Dennis have decades of knowledge at the resort as well. They are experts at assisting you with docking and properly handing the lines for you. Very professional and welcoming.
The convenience of Hotel, Tiki Bar. Silver bullet pool patio grill, Fablulous Restaurant, Many pools, Gym and amenities like the outdoor courts adds to the enjoyment.
NO Bitting bugs or Spiders either.
It's Great fun !!
Access to town and beaches via the shuttle is another plus !
by Scott w. - Verified user on Jun 16, 2026
Fantastic experience . Wonderful crew on the docks. Great dining experience. Immaculate pool and grounds.
by Ben B. - Verified user on Jun 15, 2026
We attended the Safe Harbor Adventure at Montauk Yacht Club. We were pleasantly surprised at how exceptional the Yacht Club was. We had the best burger at the poolside bar! All the food was delicious during our stay. The Dock staff was friendly and helpful. What a gorgeous piece of property. We will be back!
by David E. - Verified user on Jun 15, 2026
The Montauk Yacht Club might be the most deluxe marina in Long Island Sound.
Our 35' J105 was the only sailboat in the marina and could easily have served as a beach toy for the many 60'-120' motor yachts parked next to us. We arrived late afternoon with plenty of time to walk our dogs on the nearby nature trail, drop into one of two pools for a swim. Excellent shower adjacent to the pool.
As we arrived Saturday, there was quite the South Beach Miami scene at the nearby restaurant/bar, which we had expected and were looking forward to. We enjoyed a perfect meal of swordfish, a salad, and a couple of margaritas.
As you can imagine, everything was expensive but worth it. Happy to return in the future.
by Doug F. - Verified user on Jun 14, 2026
Absolutely loved this place but one hiccup. Internet didn’t work so missed the Knicks winning the Championship & MMA at the White House. Not good.
by Richard K. - Verified user on Jun 14, 2026
All good…but, need new floating docks … not only for convenience but these are dangerous…
About Safe Harbor Montauk Yacht Club
Situated on scenic Lake Montauk, Safe Harbor Montauk Yacht Club & Resort is The Hamptons’ premier hotel destination for summer getaways, seasonal boaters, and private events. The newly renovated luxury seaside resort & marina spans 16 acres on Lake Montauk with coastal Italian dining at Alba Spiaggia, 106 coastal-modern guest rooms & historic villas, and elevated amenities.
Named by Yachting Magazine one of the “Top Ten marina destinations in North America, Mexico and the Bahamas,” our marina is a perennial favorite among the boating community and a haven for cruisers, sport fish and mega yachts. We offer a craft capacity of 300 feet with a maximum 12 foot draft. Marina guests have full access to the resort amenities, wellness activations, and other lifestyle programming.
Booking Info
All guest boaters will be charged accordingly for the electric/power usage.
There is a 40' minimum charge for transient dockage.
The full reservation value will be collected at the time of confirmation.
Cancellation Policy: The full reservation value will be collected at the time of confirmation. From this amount, a one-night nonrefundable deposit will be charged upon confirmation for one-night reservations, while a two-night nonrefundable deposit will be charged for reservations of two nights or more.
For vessels measuring 60 feet or longer, the full reservation amount is nonrefundable due to limited slip availability.
If a reservation must be rescheduled, the one- or two-night deposit may be applied as a credit toward a future reservation anytime through October 31, 2026. Any unused credit after October 31, 2026, will be forfeited.
In the event of a cancellation made within one week of the reservation date, the full reservation value will be forfeited and retained by the marina.
Services
Amenities
Info
Photos
