by Zoltan B. - Verified user on Sep 06, 2023
Ryan and staff were very understanding and accommodating. They exhibited professionalism even late in the day when attending to three boats which arrived at once. Looking forward to next years stay there. A+ service. Thank you.
by Capt. A. - Verified user on Sep 05, 2023
Great staff, clean grounds, good restaurant. Very accommodating
by Shaun O. - Verified user on Sep 04, 2023
The dog park was an extra wonderful addition and made our stay even better
by Daniel s. - Verified user on Aug 31, 2023
Fantastic spot. Great amenities and food. The place is amazing. Our 2nd time back and won’t be out last.
by Jonathan B. - Verified user on Aug 21, 2023
Great place to stay! Clean Marina, friendly staff- would go back again!
by Chris E. - Verified user on Aug 21, 2023
Great time as always. Sam’s star island remains our favorite marina to visit.
by Kevin G. - Verified user on Jul 31, 2023
Super helpful and friendly staff, great pool, restaurant and amenities galore!
by Larry K. - Verified user on Jul 28, 2023
Clean and convenient. Great pool and food. Highly recommend
by Kivanc P. - Verified user on Jul 23, 2023
Very narrow slips. But they have a good staff.
by David S. - Verified user on Jul 23, 2023
Had a pleasant stay at star island, would recommend
by Dick H. - Verified user on Jul 16, 2023
Good Marine. Had to get use to docking stern in with only pillons on each side of the boat (no dock). Dock hands were great in assisting us.
by Suzanne F. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2023
We haven't stayed here in a long time, the facilities are nice but a few things presented the possibility for improvement.
We were given a slip number and some general directions; the slip numbers are on the dock boards so they are not viewable from the water, which kind of makes them useless to transients.
The bulk of the boats are fishing boats, so there is a lot of early morning movement. It also lends itself to piles of dock boxes and equipment being stacked on the dock. While not a big issue it did lead to a few incidents of interesting navigation walking the docks.
There were signs on several of the poles advertising live music on Saturday nights, we never heard or saw anything.
We didn't dine at the restaurant but we did get a cocktail from the bar. For a standard sized plastic cup of frozen strawberry daiquiri it was $21. I guess that's standard for Montauk?
Other than that our stay was nice. The power and water were close to our slip and worked without issue. The WiFi is probably the best I've ever seen. We only saw an outage once in the 3 days we were there and it didn't last long, outside of that incident the service was fast and reliable. Garbage cans are conveniently located and are emptied multiple times a day. The dockhands were knowledgeable and helpful. The store is very well stocked with clothing, food, fishing gear, and repair parts. The pool area is nice and their fish cleaning stations are great.
by Stephen M. - Verified user on Sep 12, 2022
Beauatiful. Staff friendly and helpful. Enjoyed talking to the season slip holders.
Slip location was easy to get to and they were able to have s dock near our travel companions.
by Kent S. on Aug 10, 2022
Another great visit to Star Island! Staff were on point as usual and the grounds/facilities were meticulous. (Pool, bathrooms, grills, corn hole, “live aquarium”) My “crew” is not used to tying to stationary pilings and the staff has been amazing when it comes to helping out both times I have been here..Stern is floating. I know it’s a little on the spendy side (what isn’t in Montauk 😉) but the restaurant makes a killer egg sandwich in the morning. Only about a 5-10 minute Uber ride into town for shops and restaurants. Definitely recommend this marina!
by Paul F. - Verified user on Aug 09, 2022
We were a group of 8 boats and we loved the marina, the facilities and staff! Well done Sam’s Star Island Marina and a big shout out to Ryan for managing our group so well.
by Harry V. - Verified user on Jul 12, 2022
Had a great stay at Sam's Star Island. Facilities were beautiful, staff was friendly. Couldn't have asked for more
by Edwin L. - Verified user on Jun 16, 2022
Great location, service was outstanding. Will definitely be going back!
Only minus was we left our dingy gas can on the dock when we left.
by Artie G. - Verified user on Oct 04, 2021
We did the catch & cook at the restaurant and by far exceeded any expectations we had. The chef is amazing. The marina is top notch as well.
by Edward R. - Verified user on Aug 29, 2021
Clean, well maintained, convenient. They even have fuel pumps on some of the docks. You can top off your tanks without even leaving the slip. All around a class operation.
by Mary C. - Verified user on Aug 27, 2021
Always love this marina. Unfortunately this year during heat wave, the pool was closed for lack of a life guard. Understand that’s a nation issue…colleges opening early. Food at the grill as incredible…breakfast and dinner. Fish tacos and tuna were to die for!
by Todd E. - Verified user on Aug 19, 2021
Great place, great staff!
by Costas K. - Verified user on Aug 15, 2021
Beautiful Marina!!! Friendly staff and very accommodating. Special thanks to the gentleman and the kid. Who helped me retrieve my phone that fell overboard. Wish I asked their names to thank them personally. Especially the kid that dove into the harbor and got it on the first try!!
Thanks again and we’ll be seeing you soon!!
by Thomas D. - Verified user on Aug 13, 2021
Just a nice clean marina and welcoming staff and just the right amount of needed facilities
by Luke R. - Verified user on Aug 11, 2021
Marina was nice, amenities were fine. The marina seems to be for fishing boats. Docks were way cluttered with, coolers, dead bait, filleted fish guts etc. Not a yachting marina. Staff were nice.
by John l. - Verified user on Aug 09, 2021
Great location and facility
by Philip M. - Verified user on Aug 01, 2021
Great marina. Kids loved the pool and catching stripers right off the dock. Ability to gas up right in your slip is fantastic.
by Peter K. - Verified user on Jul 30, 2021
Great spot, services, store and restaurant. Dockhands always around and accommodating.
by Dianik - Verified user on Jul 23, 2021
Terrible!!!!! The pool was closed because the Life guard was not available. I paid over $250 and traveled from Babylon, NY to enjoy my stay in Montauk for nothing. Will not be returning to Star Island ever again. Would give this place a zero if I could.
Hello! We are sorry to hear you did not enjoy your stay. Our lifeguard was hit by a car while riding his bike to work a couple days before. We thought it was best that he recovers from the accident prior to coming back to work. Apologies for the pool closure.
by Anthony D. - Verified user on Oct 05, 2020
Always a great time at Sam’s Star Island!
by Laura G. - Verified user on Sep 29, 2020
We love it at Star island and look forward to go every year. Wonderful service! Food and store!
by Glenn B. - Verified user on Sep 04, 2020
Great Marina! Really helpful staff. We had a minor engine problem, I mentioned it to the dockhand and he sent a mechanic right down. Had it fixed in no time.
by Jeffrey S. - Verified user on Aug 19, 2020
The staff was nice and helpful. Having fuel at every dock slip was great. Food in the restaurant was pretty good. Showers and bathroom were decent (not Old Saybrook, but much better than the Oar). Very strong fishing boat presence on the docks. In a 25 knot easterly, the water was relatively calm and protected.
by Mano M. - Verified user on Aug 02, 2020
great place - easy to get in and out of... dock hand help was great... we didn't try the restaurant as we ended up eating at other places but overall, very satisfied...
by Richard K. - Verified user on Jul 19, 2020
Generally a nice place. Has a well appointed store and a causal restaurant for breakfast lunch and dinner. Two negatives I’d say. It’s very expensive at
about $8/ ft. Store prices are similarly high. I paid $55 for a 25’ dock line I needed.
Also with a lot of fishing boats, it can sometimes get a bit noisy by about 6:30 am so not great if you want to sleep a bit late. Sunday’s seems quite than other days.
by Christina S. - Verified user on Aug 12, 2019
Awesome stay!! Staff and slips are amazing:)
by Tony M. - Verified user on Aug 11, 2019
John & the rest of the staff at Star Island are always first rate, thanks again !
by Phil M. - Verified user on Jul 28, 2019
It is a nice marina, not $252 nice. There were 4 other marinas nearby at have the cost. It is on an island so it is a mile and a half walk to the restaurants and bars. The showers while clean were claustrophobic super small shower and dressing area. Pool closed at 6pm.