Show More
by Jennifer P. - Verified user on Aug 26, 2024
We had a great stay! The staff was super friendly and helpful with docking. The restaurant food was delicious and a great setting. It is a really fun, low key place to visit.
by James m. - Verified user on Aug 23, 2024
Dick staff were very helpful, beautiful location. Restaurant and Food truck excellent. WiFi could be better, many dead spots, very sporadic
by Geraldine D. - Verified user on Aug 06, 2024
Very nice marina. Beautiful pool, great restaurant, excellent service. We will definitely be staying again!
by Larry G. - Verified user on Aug 02, 2024
Beautiful place and very attentive dock hands
by Stephen - Verified user on Jul 19, 2024
First class marina. Excellent restaurant. Meghan the manager was amazing. She drove me to town and picked me back up. She showed me unbelievable kindness.
I met with the owner and his wife while watching the band play tunes at the Shipwreck bar, which was an old schooner turned into a bar
I truly recommend stopping there next time you’re by Shelter Island.
by Lance B. - Verified user on Jul 07, 2024
Can’t say enough about this marina. Everyone is a class act. Great location that’s run great. Had an issue with a pump and their mechanics jumped in to fix it immediately.
by john H. - Verified user on Jun 24, 2024
This was our first stay and had an outstanding experience. The dock crew were great with a special shout out to Brendan for helping us initially into our slip. We definitely will be back.
Best
Annie and John H
by Joe S. - Verified user on Jun 20, 2024
Great staff, very helpful when docking
by Steven D. - Verified user on Jun 03, 2024
Beautiful place. Extremely nice and helpful staff. From owner down to dock and pool people.
by rosemary e. - Verified user on Sep 07, 2023
we've been going here for years and absolutely love this marina! it is beautiful and the location is the best! the people there are awesome! the marina is super clean, the bar and restaurant are great! We love going there every year
by Kristina T. - Verified user on Sep 06, 2023
Beautiful Marina that is well cared for, could use lighting on walkways at night.
by Bryan D. - Verified user on Sep 05, 2023
Beautiful grounds, friendly staff.scenery is fantastic
by Melanie B. - Verified user on Sep 05, 2023
East to find, helpful and attentive dock hands, live music, good food!
by Joseph S. - Verified user on Aug 27, 2023
Loved our stay. Thank you Megan for extending our stay when the weather conditions turned !
by Thomas H. - Verified user on Aug 26, 2023
Beautiful spot!
Pool, restaurant there with beaches nearby!
by Paul S. - Verified user on Aug 23, 2023
Long review but worth the read…
My wife and I have visited many marinas this year throughout eastern Long Island and this one was our favorite.
A bit tight for slipping, but nothing crazy at all. Dock hands were great and helpful. The atmosphere was fantastic, both lively and fun. Great restaurant, food trucks, outdoor bar and a great pool.
Everything was super clean and organized. Bathrooms and showers were perfect and more than one location for easy use. The grounds were very relaxing, having Adirondack under shaded trees, the docks all lead to each other so you could walk the entire marina and fantastic spaces to hang out and relax. The approach was super easy and water was deep throughout.
I did have one huge complaint that was squashed immediately. On the day of arrival it was really hot and all we wanted to do was hop in the pool, but it was closed because the life guard called in sick. I went to the office and before I could even complain, Megan the office manager said the life guard was out for the day and she would be up to the pool in a minute and open it up for us while she stood in as a lifeguard. I didn’t even ask, request or negotiate, it was the first thing she said after she said hello to me. I couldn’t believe it and totally appreciated it. She was an awesome person and went totally out of her way to make sure we were happy with our stay. She is a true asset to her employer!
To wrap it up… go and you won’t be disappointed!!!!
by Steve B. - Verified user on Aug 17, 2023
ELECTRIC SUPPLY SYSTEM DAMAGED OUR EQUIPMENT
The staff members were excellent! your “dockboys”(and girls) polite, friendly and were top notch. Everything was perfect until it was time to plug in.
EVERY ELECTRICAL DEVICE WAS DAMAGED/BURNED.
HALF OF THE OUTLETS: DEAD!
I plugged into two separate 30a burn damaged outlets. one for air conditioners the other for the rest of the boat. running 1 a/c only at 12 amps ruined my $130 30amp cord set. THE 30 amp SUPPLY COULD NOT HANDLE a 12 amp DRAW.
THE POWER INFRASTRUCTURE AT THIS MARINA IS GARBAGE AND DAMAGING TO YOUR VESSELS EQUIPMENT.
Reports to the Manager, James regarding substandard infrastructure were shrugged off. Advising him of their need for the services of an electrician, he replied that they have an electrician.
ISLAND BOATYARD NEEDS TO SECURE THE SERVICES OF A QUALIFIED ELECTRICIAN.
A shuttle is offered. Told by 2 staff members that if no one was available to drive our fellow cruisers to church on sunday, taxi fare would be reimbursed.
THIS POLICY WAS REFUSED with a denial that the reimbursement policy existed.
BAD POWER
BAD CUSTOMER POLICY
ATTENTIVE MARINA STAFF
BEAUTIFUL LOCATION
ELECTRIC SUPPLY SYSTEM DAMAGED OUR EQUIPMENT
by cameron d. - Verified user on Aug 17, 2023
We love it here. Veterans attentive staff if needed. Great view
by Robert C. - Verified user on Aug 15, 2023
The dock hands were great. The facility was clean and beautiful. The electric needs attention. They have a complementary shuttle, I was told if it was not available, take a taxi and they would reimburse me. This did not happen.
by Gregory F. - Verified user on Jul 27, 2023
This is one of our favorite places to visit. Megan is extremely helpful and responsive, the staff is terrific, dock hands are great. SALT restaurant is delicious and a great atmosphere, as is the Shipwreck. Terrific views from there also. We will make this a “must visit” at least once per season if not more.
by Kevin G. - Verified user on Jul 26, 2023
Great spot with friendly staff and the pool and restaurant top it all off!
by mark a. - Verified user on Jul 21, 2023
The grounds were beautiful. Lacking were knowledgeable dock staff (if they were 14 years old I’d be surprised): didn’t know how to tie up a line on dock, didn’t know tidal range. But they tried…. I’ll give them credit for that. The worst problem was the electrical hookups!!!!! Took seven electric stations to find one that worked all the time. Nice pool, good restaurant, good dog walking areas.
by Robert C. - Verified user on Jul 21, 2023
I was going back-and-forth on whether to leave three stars four stars or five stars. Let me tell you why I chose four stars. This marina has always been great to me and I’ve always enjoyed my stay there. The restaurant and food is fantastic. The whole feeling at this Marina is a positive one. The reason why I was going back-and-forth on whether to leave four stars or five stars. This marina has always been great to me and I’ve always enjoyed my stay there. The restaurant and food is fantastic. The whole feeling at this marina is a positive one.
They need to figure out their Internet, because the last several years I’ve gone there the Internet connection is so horrible. I couldn’t even watch a movie on TV when we were in bed at night, and the only other thing that I would suggest for them to do very nicely is put garbage cans near the marina. Yes, I know you have to have staff empty them, but we have to haul all garbage pretty far away to get to the dumpster. Besides that we love this place and we will be back.
by Shawn S. - Verified user on Jul 10, 2023
Island Boatyard is always one of our favorite destinations.
by Jefffrey H. - Verified user on Jul 02, 2023
Our family has enjoyed the island boatyard marina for years. Beautiful and relaxing. Great dock hands.
View all on Marinas.com