65 S Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Dock
Offered
Mooring
Not Offered
Day Trip
Not Offered
Book faster with the free Dockwa app
103 Reviews
by Lance B. - Verified user on Jul 05, 2026
Can’t say enough about this marina. Everyone is a class act. Great location Meghan and staff are wonderful. What marinas should be all about. They continue to be a great gem of a spot!
by Carla H. on Jul 01, 2026
From the dock hands to the bartenders, everyone at The Island Boatyard were helpful and pleasant. We stayed 2 nights. There was a wedding on the 2nd night and that was fun to watch and we had free music! They have a restaurant, Salt, and a food truck by the bar. I would definitely go back. We were also able to get a ride to town which was very nice.
by Steven D. - Verified user on Jun 29, 2026
Beautiful place. Extremely nice and helpful staff. From owner down to dock and pool people.
by James D. on Sep 24, 2025
Beautiful marina, helpful staff. We have visited quite a few times, both daily and overnight, and have truly enjoyed our stays. It's easy to take a cab to the ferry over to Greenport, which we love. My only disappointment is that the restaurant and bar shut down before the Maritime Festival takes place in Greenport, but I'm pretty sure the rates stay the same. Likely a summer-staffing issue, though. Still a great marina.
by Joseph C. - Verified user on Sep 07, 2025
We enjoyed our stay at the island boatyard in Marina. Megan, the dockmaster, was very helpful. We would definitely recommend staying there.
by rosemary e. - Verified user on Sep 02, 2025
we've been going here for years and absolutely love this marina! it is beautiful and the location is the best! the people there are awesome! Megan is always super helpful!! the marina is clean, the bar and restaurant are great! We look forward to going there every year
by Owen B. - Verified user on Aug 14, 2025
The guidance for getting in was top notch. The assistance for docking was professional and very helpful. All of the services at the marina were explained and invites to the restaurant were offered. We had a quiet and restful night. We’ll be back!
by Paul S. - Verified user on Aug 01, 2025
2nd Visit in 2 years and just as good as the 1st! Love this place and meeting other transient visitors during my stay feel the same way. It’s just a great place. Pool is awesome, outdoor bar as well and the restaurant (SALT) is so good! Megan dock master/manager is terrific and anything that may be needed is only a call to Megan and it gets done. Dock hands are fantastic and at the ready all the time. We will be back (again)!
by Kelly L. - Verified user on Jul 26, 2025
Beautiful place and everyone is so helpful. The restaurant is great too!!
by Richard G. - Verified user on Jul 24, 2025
Been coming here on and off for 30 years. The restaurant Salt has delicious food and drink, pool is uncrowded, clean and staffed by a wonderful lifeguard, bathrooms and showers are clean. Some of the younger dock crews should be a little better supervised especially on how to tie a boat to the pilings. Both stern lines were tied with loops that would only hold under constant pressure and these were not. As such when the lines were pulled they unwound from the pilings offering no holding power.
by Joseph C. - Verified user on Jul 18, 2025
The best ! The staff and amenities were fantastic
by Scott G. - Verified user on Jul 07, 2025
Always a pleasure staying there. We love the family vibe from the staff and Megan is always accomodating.
by Anonymous - Verified user on May 29, 2025
clean very peaceful small marina with bar and restaurant
by Jennifer P. - Verified user on Aug 26, 2024
We had a great stay! The staff was super friendly and helpful with docking. The restaurant food was delicious and a great setting. It is a really fun, low key place to visit.
by James m. - Verified user on Aug 23, 2024
Dick staff were very helpful, beautiful location. Restaurant and Food truck excellent. WiFi could be better, many dead spots, very sporadic
by Geraldine D. - Verified user on Aug 06, 2024
Very nice marina. Beautiful pool, great restaurant, excellent service. We will definitely be staying again!
by Larry G. - Verified user on Aug 02, 2024
Beautiful place and very attentive dock hands
by Stephen - Verified user on Jul 19, 2024
First class marina. Excellent restaurant. Meghan the manager was amazing. She drove me to town and picked me back up. She showed me unbelievable kindness.
I met with the owner and his wife while watching the band play tunes at the Shipwreck bar, which was an old schooner turned into a bar
I truly recommend stopping there next time you’re by Shelter Island.
by john H. - Verified user on Jun 24, 2024
This was our first stay and had an outstanding experience. The dock crew were great with a special shout out to Brendan for helping us initially into our slip. We definitely will be back.
Best
Annie and John H
by Joe S. - Verified user on Jun 20, 2024
Great staff, very helpful when docking
by Kristina T. - Verified user on Sep 06, 2023
Beautiful Marina that is well cared for, could use lighting on walkways at night.
by Bryan D. - Verified user on Sep 05, 2023
Beautiful grounds, friendly staff.scenery is fantastic
by Melanie B. - Verified user on Sep 05, 2023
East to find, helpful and attentive dock hands, live music, good food!
by Jeannine S. - Verified user on Aug 27, 2023
Loved our stay. Thank you Megan for extending our stay when the weather conditions turned !
by Thomas H. - Verified user on Aug 26, 2023
Beautiful spot!
Pool, restaurant there with beaches nearby!
About The Island Boatyard & Marina
The Island Boatyard and Marina is located on Shelter Island, New York, which sits between the north and south forks of Long Island. Specifically, we are in West Neck Harbor, which is known for its natural buffers that limit wave and wind action for your boat's protection and your comfort. We have 75 slips that can accommodate power and sail boats from 15 feet to 60 feet. Overnight transient slips are also available and include access to our pool (open June 25th), restaurant, outdoor bar, and complimentary shuttle van, which can take you anywhere on the island. Similarly, we offer slips for SALT restaurant guests. Slips for the restaurant are available on a first-come, first-served basis and are $1.00 per foot for two hours. Gas, diesel, and ice are available 7 days a week at our fuel dock, as well as our newly installed sanitation pump out system open from 8am-6pm.
Services
Amenities
Info
Photos
